Sunday, February 21, 2016

The Influence of News Media on Millennials

By Chris La Bella

A 2014 study conducted by the Pew Research Center found that millennials are the most liberal generation. Around half of individuals between the age of 18 and 34 identify as Democrat, compared to the 34% who lean Republican (Kiley, 2014). With this said, a major area of interest nowadays is the relationship between news media and millennials. As news media change in nature, adapting to developing platforms like social networks and such, their influence on the public continues to expand. Now, everyone has heard the notion that the media has a liberal bias, but there may be a connection here. The fact that millennials, a generation with profound knowledge and consumption of media, are primarily liberal may serve as proof that news media serve as a catalyst of liberalism.
 
One thing to consider about news media is their growing presence in our everyday lives through services like Facebook and Twitter. These social networks follow us around in our pockets at all times, making them ideal platforms for news media to tap into as 91% of millennials keep their phones less than a meter away (Wallace, 2013). In fact, Facebook exceeds every other source for political news with 61% of millennials using the site over sources like CNN, Fox News, or local TV (Mitchell, 2015). Facebook and Twitter have a strong grip when it comes to providing users with information, and with that power comes the ability to promote a certain agenda. If one takes a minute to consider the “suggested” posts that he or she has come across recently, perhaps it was a NowThis Election or Politico video critiquing Ted Cruz or explaining why Bernie Sanders and socialism is great for America. Maybe it was Buzzfeed’s patronizing post titled “18 Things Donald Trump Has 100% Actually Said.” The main idea here is that news media are using highly popular mediums like Facebook to promote a liberal stance. And, these sites are letting them. Unsurprisingly, there aren’t metrics showing the number of suggested posts supporting liberal candidates and policies compared to conservative ones. If there were, the number of conservative posts would be very minimal. In our digital age where social media has become a vital aspect of life for our generation, of course the constant bombardment of liberal notions through suggested posts can persuade individuals (especially those lacking interest in politics) into thinking a certain way. This way of thinking just happens to be liberal.
 
At a basic level, comparing the amount of liberal and conservative networks on television will demonstrate a similar idea. While young independents and conservatives can turn to Fox News (only) to receive trustworthy political information in their eyes, liberals have a range of options with networks like CNN, MSNBC, CBS, and ABC. Obviously, the more networks promoting a similar agenda, the greater chance of individuals adopting a certain ideology as a result. This seems to be the case for millennials. The fact that there is only one somewhat conservative network, compared to the handful of liberal networks, demonstrates that the media is liberal by nature. And, news media only show signs of growing more and more “progressive.” Consider how many conservative commentators and authors have stopped appearing on Fox News alone. Individuals like Lou Dobbs, Glenn Beck, and Michelle Malkin rarely appear on the network anymore; a network that has the image of being ultra conservative. If this was truly the case, then wouldn’t these right wing individuals continue to offer their political insight regularly? Instead, they have been replaced with more center-left analysts, diluting yet another conservative source of information with liberalism. Happenings like this may then account for the fact that Republican millennials express less conservative values than do their elders according to research by Pew Research Center (Kiley, 2014).
 
Lastly, the liberal agenda radiating from the majority of news media may come from the simple fact that more journalists identify as Democrats. According to a 2013 survey by Indiana University, 28.1% of journalists said they were Democrats compared to just 7.1% of journalists claiming to be Republican (Thompson, 2014). Keep in mind that 18% identified as Republican in 2002. With this said, the influx in liberal content makes perfect sense then. A decrease in conservative individuals working in news media means there is more liberal content circulating. Therefore, the audience of news media, specifically the millennial audience in this case, is prone to accept the liberal slant as a “normal” perception since there are more sources preaching the same belief. While the liberal agenda may not be completely forced on individuals, it seems to inherently exist within news media, further demeaning conservatism as the years go on. Thus, millennials may serve as a prime example of a generation purely influenced by the intensifying liberal agenda within temporary news media. Let’s see how things turn out for Generation Z.

Works Cited

Kiley, J. (2014, September). The GOP’s Millennial problem runs deep. In Pew Research Center. Retrieved February 21, 2016, from http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/09/25/the-gops-millennial-problem-runs-deep/

Mitchell, A., Gottfried, J., & Eva Matsa, K. (2015, June 1). Millennials and Political News. In Pew Research Center. Retrieved February 21, 2016, from http://www.journalism.org/2015/06/01/millennials-political-news/

Thompson, D. (2014, May). Report: Journalists Are Miserable, Liberal, Over-Educated, Under-Paid, Middle-Aged Men. In The Atlantic. Retrieved February 21, 2016, from http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/05/report-journalists-are-miserable-over-educated-under-paid-middle-aged-men-mostly/361891/


Wallace, B. (2013). Here come the... millennials. The Enterprise, 43(5), 2. Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/1443488597?accountid=13381

3 comments:

  1. Hi Chris!

    In your first paragraph you mentioned, “Now, everyone has heard the notion that the media has a liberal bias, but there may be a connection here. The fact that millennials, a generation with profound knowledge and consumption of media, are primarily liberal may serve as proof that news media serve as a catalyst of liberalism.” I really found this to be an interesting point you made about the media and its liberal bias having a connection with millennials. I never thought about it that way and I think you make a valid point. I couldn’t agree with you more for many years mainstream media has dominated the airwaves along with academia pushing the liberal ideology. However, with the advent of Fox News and more nationally recognized radio talk show hosts we are beginning to see more of a fair and balance point of view and a shift in the balance of power.

    It makes sense that the news media is channeling their news heavily through social media platforms in order to get to millennials. I know by experience that I come across news articles at random while I am scrolling through my feed on Facebook and Twitter. In the article, "How Millennials Get News", during their study the asked a millennial how she gets her news and her response is, ‘“Social media keeps me more informed than I could be with the other forms of news,” said Elese, a 25-year-old in Chicago. “By quickly scrolling through my feed, I can see the major stories going on. If I need to read deeper into it, I can go to a credible source’s website”’ (The Media Insight Project: "How Millennials Get News."). These networks, which are predominately liberal bias, are purposefully exposing millennials to their news through social media platforms knowing that it is the best way to obtain the attention of my generation. Pew Research Center conducted a report on the progression of news on Facebook ad Twitter. Here are their findings, “On both Facebook and Twitter, more users are getting news than in the past. As of early 2015, 63% of Facebook and Twitter users get news on their respective sites. This is up substantially from 2013, when about half of each social network’s users (47% for Facebook and 52% for Twitter) reported getting news there” (Mitchell, A. and Page, D.) Because millennials are avid social media users they are more incline to come across the liberal ideology on these social media platforms making them lean more to the left. Chris, I thought that your blog post was an eye-opening topic, followed with a sturdy and valid case. The influence of news media on millennials is strong. I believe it should not lean in one direction of political views but should be fair so that millennials can make an honest choice.


    Works Cited

    "How Millennials Get News." The Media Insight Project. March 2015. Web.



    Mitchell, Amy and Dana Page. "The Evolving Role of News on Twitter and Facebook." Pew Research Center. 15 July 2015. Web.



    ReplyDelete
  2. Chris, I think you brought up some interesting points. You pointed out “In our digital age where social media has become a vital aspect of life for our generation, of course the constant bombardment of liberal notions through suggested posts can persuade individuals (especially those lacking interest in politics) into thinking a certain way. This way of thinking just happens to be liberal.” I really have never thought of it that way. This could be held very true. I was raised with my parents being Republican’s, but to be honest, I don’t have a clue what I am, and I’m pretty sure most of the things that I agree with are liberal. (Except for anything Obama stands for). The reason for this is because everything I read on Facebook or any type of social media, gears me towards that. “When it comes to where younger Americans get news about politics and government, social media look to be the local TV of the Millennial generation. About six-in-ten online Millennials (61%) report getting political news on Facebook in a given week” (Mitchell, Page 2).

    To be honest with you, it was a little difficult for me to follow your post. Nothing against your writing or your layout, because I thought it was very well done, but I am so blind and deaf to anything regarding politics that when I read anything regarding them – it’s hard for me to comprehend and follow – let alone respond to it.

    My deficiency to understanding politics can actually be linked to how these social media outlets portray current issues and debates. Everything on social media regarding Donald Trump is somehow made into some sort of gag, or joke. Thanks to SNL, I know that Donald Trump and Jeb Bush get into some pretty funny/heated arguments. But how much of it is sincere? Also, looking at what you said about the TV networks – “Obviously, the more networks promoting a similar agenda, the greater chance of individuals adopting a certain ideology as a result. This seems to be the case for millennials.” This is true in the sense that most TV news outlets are coming at the their audience from a liberal standpoint – it’s giving us no choice but to express a liberal point of view. However, “When it comes to choosing a media source for political news, conservatives orient strongly around Fox News. Nearly half of consistent conservatives (47%) name it as their main source for government and political news, as do almost a third (31%) of those with mostly conservative views. No other sources come close” (Mitchell 2014).

    WORK CITED:
    Mitchell. Amy and Dana Page. "Millennials and Political News: Social
    Media - Local TV for the Next Generation?" Pew Research Center.
    June 2015. Web.



    Lang, Brent. “CNN Becoming Like Fox News, MSNBC.” The Wrap.March. 2013. Web.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is a really interesting topic. I've never really looked into how the news presents its' topics in a way that promotes a political bias. I don't consider myself a Democrat or a Republican, but I'm definitely more on the liberal side of things. You mentioned, "The main idea here is that news media are using highly popular mediums like Facebook to promote a liberal stance" and I think this about sums it up. Since millennials use a lot of social media, it would make sense that news orgs would try to target them specifically on sites like Facebook and Twitter. I personally find this generation to be a lot less traditional than previous generations, which may explain why we tend to be more liberal.

    I think it also has a lot to do with who you follow and what you surround yourself with. A lot of people get their news because of things that their friends are posting, and "Millennials also appear to be drawn into news that they might otherwise have ignored because peers are recommending and contextualizing it for them on social networks, as well as on more private networks such as group texts and instant messaging" ("How Millennials Get News"). If you follow a lot of liberally minded people, you're going to be more inclined to get liberal biased news on your feed. If a lot of your friends are heated about one subject (for example, the Kesha vs. Dr. Luke debacle) you're more likely to look into it or have an opinion on it. It's no longer about being informed, it's more about being "in the know" which is a lot more to do with having something to discuss with people.

    We're constantly surrounded by news now, and "As of early 2015, 63% of Facebook and Twitter users get news on their respective sites" (Mitchell, A. and Page, D.). That's a lot of people getting news every day. Do people our age even turn on the TV to get news anymore? I know I don't. I depend on websites and my newsfeed to get the news that I want to look at. Since it's easy to filter out things that I don't want to see on the web, I'm not forced to watch segments on the news about other things. I can control my own bias. In this sense, I'm not sure if millennials are more liberal because of the bias of the news but because they can pick what they want to look at now. If there is a segment on why guns should be legal for everyone to use and purchase, I'll probably skip over it because I don't agree with it. If I had to depend on TV, I'd have to watch it. We have more of a choice now.

    -

    Mitchell, Amy and Dana Page. "The Evolving Role of News on Twitter and Facebook." Pew Research Center. 15 July 2015. Web.



    Young, Eric. "How Millennials Get News." The Media Insight Project. March 2015. Web.



    ReplyDelete